Q. “New Social Movements in developing societies represent a shift from class-based politics to identity- and issue-based mobilization.” Critically examine this statement with reference to India.
(15 Marks)
How to Approach
Define New Social Movements (NSMs) first, explain why they differ from traditional class-based movements, then examine how India reflects this shift through identity- and issue-based mobilization. Finally, critically assess whether class politics has actually disappeared or merely evolved.
Answer
New Social Movements (NSMs) emerged from the 1970s onwards as collective mobilizations centred on identity, rights, environment, gender, ethnicity and democratic participation, rather than solely on class struggle or economic redistribution. Scholars such as Alain Touraine and Alberto Melucci argue that contemporary conflicts increasingly revolve around culture, identity and quality of life rather than ownership of the means of production.
Unlike traditional labour and peasant movements, many contemporary Indian movements are organised around caste, gender, ethnicity and sexuality. The Dalit movement, women's movement, tribal assertions and LGBTQ+ rights movement seek dignity, recognition and equal citizenship alongside socio-economic justice. These movements challenge structures of exclusion rather than merely demanding economic redistribution.
Environmental and rights-based campaigns have expanded the scope of collective action. The Chipko Movement, Narmada Bachao Andolan, Right to Information movement and Right to Food campaign focused on ecological justice, displacement, transparency and accountability rather than class conflict alone. Digital mobilizations such as #MeToo India further illustrates decentralized, network-based activism centred on specific issues.
However, the shift is not absolute. Economic inequalities continue to shape many movements. Farmers' protests, labour mobilizations and struggles of informal workers remain deeply rooted in questions of livelihood and redistribution. Moreover, identity and class frequently intersect. As Ghanshyam Shah observes, Indian social movements often combine caste, class and democratic rights instead of replacing one with another.
India's New Social Movements represent an expansion rather than a replacement of class politics. They have broadened the political agenda by incorporating identity, rights and environmental concerns while continuing to reflect underlying socio-economic inequalities characteristic of developing societies.
PSIR Test Series (16 Tests) + Mentorship
Questions prepared keeping in mind the changing nature of UPSC CSE