UPSC Mains Directive Words

UPSC Mains

Discuss, Explain, Analyse, Examine, Evaluate


Table of contents

These key words make a regular appearance in UPSC CSE mains. All you need to do is open up a paper from GS1, 2, or 3 and these words stare at you in each question.

Don’t believe me? Here are some examples:

GS1 Mains 2020

There’s more where that came from:

GS2 Mains 2020

And still more:

GS3 Mains 2019

And understanding what you need to do in each case can be problematic at times. Because if you don’t know what those words mean, then you don’t know what to do when you see them.

Which brings us to the main topic of conversation today:

Levels of Knowledge

Yes, there are levels of knowledge. And we will be discussing a particular schema called Bloom’s Taxonomy of knowledge.

What is this Bloom’s Taxonomy?

Do you need to take notes? NO.

Instead, focus on understanding the concept here.

To grasp what’s happening at each of these levels let’s take up an example.

We’ll use a simple fact, that Dr. Ambedkar is the father of the Indian constitution, and try to analyse it from multiple angles.

Level 1 - Remember

Keywords: define

Fact - Dr. Ambedkar is the father of the Indian constitution.

You remembered this from a sentence ago? Congratulations! You’ve got level 1 skills.

Level 2 - Understand

Keywords: explain

To understand a fact you need to know the meaning behind it.

For example: Dr. Ambedkar is the father of the Indian Constitution, does this mean he gave birth to a book or does this means that he was the head of the Drafting Committee? I’m more inclined to go with the latter.

Level 3 - Apply

Keywords: Apply, justify, discuss, explain with examples

Coming to application, this is where the abstract fun begins. Given that you have understood a concept, you must be able to take it out of the environment where you found it apply it as per it’s rules in new surroundings.

For example: continuing with Dr. Ambedkar’s example we can move ahead and say that since he just headed the Drafting Committee, there must have been others who also contributed to the developement of the Indian Constitution.

And indeed there were. The Constitution was put through extensive debates in the Constituent Assembly sessions with multiple changes, additions and subtractions from the original draft by Dr. Ambedkar.

Level 4 - Analyse

Keywords: analyse, comment,

At this stage, we’re playing with abstractions.

Analysis means that you take a concept, break it down into parts and then look at how those parts combine with each other.

For example: Dr. Ambedkar was chosen as the head of the Drafting Committee? Why? To ensure that the constitution was inclusive and acceptable to all.

Level 5 - Evaluate

Keywords: critically examine, critically analyse, evaluate, comment

This is the fun part. This is where knowledge interacts with values. The term e-valu-ate is a compound which is built around the core of a value.

So in order to evaluate a fact, you must be clear on your values. For UPSC CSE aspirants that’s easy, your values should be based on constitutional values of justice, equality, liberty and fraternity. When in doubt, stick to fundamental rights.

Based on those values you evaluate whether a fact is good or bad.

Continuing with the example: Did selecting Dr. Ambedkar help us indeed create an inclusive constitution? Was he the right choice for being the Father of the Indian Constitution?

I’m sure you’re familiar with the famous quote:

“To educate a man in the mind and not in moral is to educate a menace to society.”

- Theodore Roosevelt

Particularly because this quote was given as an essay topic in recent years.

Evaluation is what Mr. Roosevelt was talking about. That you may have all the information and be capable of analysis, but till you’re unable to assign a good or bad value to those facts you might end up becoming a menace to society.

Level 6 - Create

This is the part where new knowledge is created. This is the domain of PhD scholars and researchers.

And technically, creating new knowledge during the exam is frowned upon, so best to avoid this level. :P

UPSC CSE Relevance

The first three levels, remembering, understanding and applying are important for UPSC CSE Prelims. Because that’s a fact heavy part of the exam.

The levels of application, analysis and evaluation are important for UPSC CSE Mains. As you can see from the snippets shared above, the questions use these terms directly. So having a deeper understanding of how they work is essential in order for you to improve your score.

In mains, you can’t get by with just facts. You must understand how the facts interact and change the trajectory of the future because of their interactions. This is the hard part, the unspoken part about UPSC CSE preparation.

You will not find this in any books. This is the part of UPSC preparation where you must learn to think for yourself.

But once you start, there’s no looking back.

Endnotes

When I started my UPSC preparation back in 2014, I had some realisation that this existed. But apart from the knowledge of these levels, I was unable to apply them. It was confusing and frustrating more so because now I knew how much I didn’t know, so it was a step in the right direction.

Yet I still did not know how I could work to improve where I stood.

Over time I found some great resources, which I will share in the next post.

Till next time!


Test Series + Mentorship


Previous Post

Next Post