UPSC Mains Daily Answer Writing (16-09-2022)

UPSC Mains Daily Answer Writing

Ethics Case Study Writing Practice


Questions

Case Study: You are a senior civil servant. One of your officer friend is hard working, completes her work on time but always demoralizes her subordinates by blaming them for one or the other thing. She keeps everyone on toes. Often she shouts in her office and want to just follow the blue book while working. She also insults junior officers if one fails to get the things done. Her only mantra to work is to "get the things done -whatever it takes." Due to this bossy attitude your friend is not liked by the subordinates and because of her uneven relation with her team members; she fails to portray a good office culture. Most of the colleagues know about this case but no one wants to discuss it because of your proximity with that lady officer. However one day one close friend happens to be your colleague who is briefed about the problem subordinate officers are facing.

Suggest Different options. Bring merits and demerits related to each course of action and discuss the best option.

Integrated Prelims + Mains Test Series
For UPSC Prelims and Mains 2023
Test series with one-to-one Mentorship!

Model Solutions

You are a senior civil servant. One of your officer friend is hard working, completes her work on time but always demoralizes her subordinates by blaming them for one or the other thing. She keeps everyone on toes. Often she shouts in her office and want to just follow the blue book while working. She also insults junior officers if one fails to get the things done. Her only mantra to work is to "get the things done -whatever it takes." Due to this bossy attitude your friend is not liked by the subordinates and because of her uneven relation with her team members; she fails to portray a good office culture. Most of the colleagues know about this case but no one wants to discuss it because of your proximity with that lady officer. However one day one close friend happens to be your colleague who is briefed about the problem subordinate officers are facing.

Suggest Different options. Bring merits and demerits related to each course of action and discuss the best option.

Model Solutions

(a) Directly talk to subordinates and assure them about correcting the things in future.

  • Directly listening to them will instill confidence in the system that their views are properly heard.
  • However, directly talking to the subordinates and bypassing the hierarchy system will set wrong precedence.
  • Thus before taking any action or consoling for any action, the senior civil servant should talk to the officer friend to get proper information about the factual situation.
  • This may also lead to decrement in trust of subordinates as they may think the above stated action has been impartial.
    (b) Give responsibility to your friend who briefed you about this case.
  • This will be the wrong course of action as delegating power to someone else in such sensitive issues may deteriorate the work culture more.

(c) Transfer the lady officer as this case may bring sorry figure for you also in future.

  • Transfer of the lady can act as the short-term measure but without giving due chance to her to explain her position will set wrong precedence and it is also against the good leadership quality.
    (c) Request the lady officer not to do so as this may hamper their personal relations also
  • In public relationships the individual relations takes a back seat and interest of larger society takes over. This requires fair and reliable decision-making to create public trust and level the playing field.
  • Requests can be done at personal level, but being a civil servant the dignity and integrity of the post has to be maintained. He has to act as a role model for the other subordinates.
    (d) Is there any better option available to correct the things other than what mentioned above?
  • I will inform him about the situation and give her last warning to improve her behavior. If she failed then move for appropriate action to maintain the work culture as well as trust between the senior and subordinates.
Previous Post

Next Post